Analysis of S.2002: “Mental Health and Safe Communities Act of 2015”

For the past few days, we’ve been waiting to see the text of Senator Cornyn’s bill. It has not appeared yet at Thomas, but I managed to find it in the Congressional Record. It is not a short bill, but quite a lot of it is really just related to mental health, and has nothing to do with gun laws. I find the NRA’s statements about the bill to be credible. S.2002 would give us, for the first time since the Gun Control Act passed, a very precise definition of what it means to be “adjudicated.” The meat of the bill is here:



SEC. 302. DEFINITIONS RELATING TO MENTAL HEALTH.

  (a) Title 18 Definitions.--Chapter 44 of title 18, United 
  States Code, is amended--
  (1) in section 921(a), by adding at the end the following:
``(36)(A) Subject to subparagraph (B), the term `has been 
  adjudicated mentally incompetent or has been committed to a 
  psychiatric hospital', with respect to a person--
``(i) means the person is the subject of an order or 
  finding by a judicial officer, court, board, commission, or 
  other adjudicative body--

``(I) that was issued after--

``(aa) a hearing--
``(AA) of which the person received actual notice; and
``(BB) at which the person had an opportunity to 
  participate with counsel; or
``(bb) the person knowingly and intelligently waived the 
  opportunity for a hearing--
``(AA) of which the person received actual notice; and
``(BB) at which the person would have had an opportunity to 
  participate with counsel; and

``(II) that found that the person, as a result of marked 
  subnormal intelligence, mental impairment, mental illness, 
  incompetency, condition, or disease--

``(aa) was a danger to himself or herself or to others;
``(bb) was guilty but mentally ill in a criminal case, in a 
  jurisdiction that provides for such a verdict;
``(cc) was not guilty in a criminal case by reason of 
  insanity or mental disease or defect;
``(dd) was incompetent to stand trial in a criminal case;
``(ee) was not guilty by reason of lack of mental 
  responsibility under section 850a of title 10 (article 50a of 
  the Uniform Code of Military Justice);
``(ff) required involuntary inpatient treatment by a 
  psychiatric hospital for any reason, including substance 
  abuse; or
``(gg) required involuntary outpatient treatment by a 
  psychiatric hospital based on a finding that the person is a 
  danger to himself or herself or to others; and
``(ii) does not include--

``(I) an admission to a psychiatric hospital for 
  observation; or
``(II) a voluntary admission to a psychiatric hospital.

``(B) In this paragraph, the term `order or finding' does 
  not include--
``(i) an order or finding that has expired or has been set 
  aside or expunged;
``(ii) an order or finding that is no longer applicable 
  because a judicial officer, court, board, commission, or 
  other adjudicative body has found that the person who is the 
  subject of the order or finding--

``(I) does not present a danger to himself or herself or to 
  others;
``(II) has been restored to sanity or cured of mental 
  disease or defect;
``(III) has been restored to competency; or
``(IV) no longer requires involuntary inpatient or 
  outpatient treatment by a psychiatric hospital; or

``(iii) an order or finding with respect to which the 
  person who is subject to the order or finding has been 
  granted relief from disabilities under section 925(c), under 
  a program described in section 101(c)(2)(A) or 105 of the 
  NICS Improvement Amendments Act of 2007 (18 U.S.C. 922 note), 
  or under any other State-authorized relief from disabilities 
  program of the State in which the original commitment or 
  adjudication occurred.
``(37) The term `psychiatric hospital' includes a mental 
  health facility, a mental hospital, a sanitarium, a 
  psychiatric facility, and any other facility that provides 
  diagnoses or treatment by licensed professionals of mental 
  retardation or mental illness, including a psychiatric ward 
  in a general hospital.''; and
  (2) in section 922--
  (A) in subsection (d)(4)--
  (i) by striking ``as a mental defective'' and inserting 
``mentally incompetent''; and
  (ii) by striking ``any mental institution'' and inserting 
``a psychiatric hospital''; and
  (B) in subsection (g)(4)--
  (i) by striking ``as a mental defective or who has'' and 
  inserting ``mentally incompetent or has''; and
  (ii) by striking ``mental institution'' and inserting 
``psychiatric hospital''.
  (b) Technical and Conforming Amendment.--The NICS 
  Improvement Amendments Act of 2007 (18 U.S.C. 922 note) is 
  amended--
  (1) by striking ``as a mental defective'' each place that 
  term appears and inserting ``mentally incompetent'';
  (2) by striking ``mental institution'' each place that term 
  appears and inserting ``psychiatric hospital'';
  (3) in section 101(c)--
  (A) in paragraph (1), in the matter preceding subparagraph 
  (A), by striking ``to the mental health of a person'' and 
  inserting ``to whether a person is mentally incompetent''; 
  and
  (B) in paragraph (2)--
  (i) in subparagraph (A)(i), by striking ``to the mental 
  health of a person'' and inserting ``to whether a person is 
  mentally incompetent''; and
  (ii) in subparagraph (B), by striking ``to the mental 
  health of a person'' and inserting ``to whether a person is 
  mentally incompetent''; and
  (4) in section 102(c)(3)--
  (A) in the paragraph heading, by striking ``as a mental 
  defective or committed to a mental institution'' and 
  inserting ``mentally incompetent or committed to a 
  psychiatric hospital''; and
  (B) by striking ``mental institutions'' and inserting 
``psychiatric hospitals''.

Someone had asked me earlier if this would fix the problem with observational commitments under Section 302 of Pennsylvania’s Mental Health Procedures Act. The answer is yes, for federal purposes. But 302 observational commitments are still disabling under Pennsylvania law. California has a similar observational commitment called a 5150, and again, this won’t count as a disability under federal law anymore, but California still bars people who have 5150 commitments from possessing firearms for 5 years. This is the same under Florida’s Baker Act as well.

But what about the veterans who have already been put into the system? Under the NICS Improvement Amendment Act of 2007, veterans could petition to have themselves removed from the system. The act requires that the Attorney General provide written notice to every person with a record in the system for mental health disabilities, and informing them of their right to petition to have themselves removed:

SEC. 304. PROTECTING THE SECOND AMENDMENT RIGHTS OF VETERANS.

  (a) In General.--Chapter 55 of title 38, United States 
  Code, is amended by adding at the end the following:

``Sec. 5511. Conditions for treatment of certain persons as 
  adjudicated mentally incompetent for certain purposes

``(a) Protecting Rights of Veterans With Existing 
  Records.--Not later than 90 days after the date of enactment 
  of the Mental Health and Safe Communities Act of 2015, the 
  Secretary shall provide written notice in accordance with 
  subsection (b) of the opportunity for administrative review 
  under subsection (c) to all persons who, on the date of 
  enactment of the Mental Health and Safe Communities Act of 
  2015, are considered to have been adjudicated mentally 
  incompetent or committed to a psychiatric hospital under 
  subsection (d)(4) or (g)(4) of section 922 of title 18 as a 
  result of having been found by the Department to be mentally 
  incompetent.
``(b) Notice.--The Secretary shall provide notice under 
  this section to a person described in subsection (a) that 
  notifies the person of--
``(1) the determination made by the Secretary;
``(2) a description of the implications of being considered 
  to have been adjudicated mentally incompetent or committed to 
  a psychiatric hospital under subsection (d)(4) or (g)(4) of 
  section 922 of title 18; and
``(3) the right of the person to request a review under 
  subsection (c)(1).
``(c) Administrative Review.--
``(1) Request.--Not later than 30 days after the date on 
  which a person described in subsection (a) receives notice in 
  accordance with subsection (b), such person may request a 
  review by the board designed or established under paragraph 
  (2) or by a court of competent jurisdiction to assess whether 
  the person is a danger to himself or herself or to others. In 
  such assessment, the board may consider the person's 
  honorable discharge or decorations.
``(2) Board.--Not later than 180 days after the date of 
  enactment of the Mental Health and Safe Communities Act of 
  2015, the Secretary shall designate or establish a board that 
  shall, upon request of a person under paragraph (1), assess 
  whether the person is a danger to himself or herself or to 
  others.
``(d) Judicial Review.--A person may file a petition with a 
  Federal court of competent jurisdiction for judicial review 
  of an assessment of the person under subsection (c) by the 
  board designated or established under subsection (c)(2).''.

Not quite as good as simple removing all the records the VA placed in their entirety, but I suspect there was some concern some of those people might legitimately belong in there, and separating the wheat from the chaff would be too tall an order.

Overall this bill would be an improvement over the current status quo, since it offers a good bit more precision. So far only NAGR has come out against the bill, which is not surprising. So far GOA has been silent on S.2002 as far as I’ve seen, even though they vociferously opposed NIAA in 2007, which was also a major easement of the mental health provisions of the Gun Control Act. Perhaps GOA is waiting to see language, or will just remain silent about the bill. This bill really is an improvement. There are always going to be folks out there who will be satisfied with nothing less than total repeal of the Gun Control Act, and I don’t blame them. But guns for crazy people isn’t a hill I’m looking to die on.

Why Would Anyone Need a Gun in a National Park?

A Rough and Tumble With a GrizzlyThankfully, we can now carry in National Parks if the local laws permit it. Unfortunately for one 63 year old Montana man, hiking alone and off-trail while unarmed turn out to be a fatal proposition. Yes, I would carry in a National Park, anti-gun folks, because I have no desire for my mortal remains to include a few dozen pounds of bear poop.

 

Crosby was the sixth person killed since 2010 by grizzlies in the greater Yellowstone area, which has an estimated 750 grizzlies and includes the park and surrounding portions of Montana, Idaho and Wyoming.

Encounters between humans and grizzlies bears have risen sharply in recent decades as the region’s grizzly population expanded. But relatively few lead to death or injury, and park officials say the risk of being attacked by a bear is comparable to the chances of being struck by lightning.

Yeah, and despite the risk of being struck by lightning being very small, years ago when I was hiking in the Northern Rockies, I learned the hard way why it’s advisable to clear off mountain peaks before the afternoon comes around and storms start brewing. I wasn’t hit, but I did learn from a far closer vantage point than I was comfortable with that rocks can be blown apart by lightning strikes. The storm came up on the other side of the mountain, and I never saw it coming. This was before the days when you could just pull up the weather radar on your phone. I will tell you, I was not feeling very comforted by the statistic that I’m very unlikely to get struck by lightning. By the same token, I doubt a hiker who comes across a big ol’ grizzly bear is likely to be very comforted by the fact that he’s very unlikely to be eaten. I wouldn’t hike up a mountain in a summer afternoon, and I wouldn’t hike in grizzly country without a proper hand cannon either.

Unexpected Ad Buy in GOP Debates

Given the ratings the debate got, this was probably money well spent. But Everytown has been working hard to distance their brand from Bloomberg. I think we constantly need to remind the public that Everytown is Bloomberg. The gun control movement, at this point, is Bloomberg. One very rich man is all that’s keeping this issue alive.

First 2016 GOP Debate

Fox News sponsored the main event, and as a cord cutter, I had to rely on audio feeds which kept cutting out, so I probably only heard 1/3rd of it. Based on everything I heard and commentary I read, I really want to like Carly Fiorina, but I keep thinking “I just hope she would run the country better than she ran HP.” Then again, I’m not sure any of the other people up on the stage in either party could have run HP better, let alone the country.

I have to admit to thinking SMOD2016 isn’t looking too bad right now. But ultimately I am an optimist. It’s pretty clear the establishment is desperate to knock Trump off the hill. In this I join with the establishment. I don’t like Trump, and think he’s a stalking horse for the Clintons. I worry Scott Walker is too much of a willing culture warrior, ready to make the election about abortion and gay marriage when the country is worried about jobs and immigration. Rubio has JFKesque political talents, for good times, but these are not good times. Half the battle might just be recognizing that, and channeling voter anxiety. The reason Trump is the man to beat right now is he’s doing that better than all the other candidates.

Oh yeah, and Christie is definitely a “law and order” Republican. I can’t get behind Rand because I think the next President has a huge foreign policy mess to deal with. I believe we are headed for another Cuban Missile Crisis type showdown with the Russians. It will happen in my lifetime. But Christie seems eager to defend the surveillance police state. No thanks. I get the impression he’d be willing to promise people anything if it “kept us safe.” I’ve had enough of that since 9/11.

Kathy Kane’s Uppance Has Come

Attorney General Kathleen Kane has been indicted this morning by the Montgomery County District Attorney for leaking grand jury information, and then attempting to cover it up. This woman has been slimy from the minute Bloomberg helped buy her office. Remember, she did not run on gun control; she exploited the Penn State scandal, and people’s anger with Corbett over that scandal, to sail into office. The Montgomery County DA Risa Vetri Ferman, is a Republican, so I would expect at least some accusations of a partisan witch hunt to be tossed around, but probably not much. She’s pooped in a lot of other people’s pools, and even many Democrats are sick of her. No doubt Seth Williams is smiling coyly today.

Now the question is whether she will resign. I sincerely hope so. I doubt that will do much to help our reciprocity agreements, since Kane’s replacement was picked by her, but it’s time to be over this controversy. Kane was considered a rising star in Pennsylvania Democratic Politics. Now she’s ruined. She’ll be lucky if Orange doesn’t end up becoming the New Black for her.

Bloomberg’s Gun Control Lite Media Project Spins

The Trace spins so fast you could enrich uranium over the Cornyn bill, because supposedly it pushes the debate onto friendlier ground for them. They aren’t happy, however, about all the veterans that will get yanked out of NICS under the bill because there was insufficient due process given to them. I have a very small violin to play for them.

We’ve seen this before, because history has repeated itself. We trade more incentives for the states to report records to the federal system, and get something in return: this time gutting the Administration’s program to strip veterans of Second Amendment rights, and a halt to any plan to do the same for some Social Security recipients. This has been done several times now. The first time Congress did this, if you recall, the Brady Campaign declared outright victory over the NICS Improvement Amendments Act (NIAA), even though the bill created a relief from disability program for the first time since the Gun Control Act passed. Prior to 2008, mental health disabilities were irrevocable lifetime prohibitions. You might recall that back in 2007, VPC were the only anti-gun group willing to call bullshit on the deal, but VPC has always had the luxury of being able to rely on a few big foundations for its existence.

That bill had weaknesses, however, as the Administration is currently exploiting, because it only provided for relief after the fact, and did not do enough to define criteria for placement in the system in the first place. This latest improvement should remove those veterans that have been screwed out of their rights, and put the onus on the VA to show they’ve been legally adjudicated, meaning that they were judged to be a danger to themselves or others by “court, board, commission or other lawful authority,” which presumably will not be some bureaucrat at the VA making a determination based solely on financial considerations. We still need to see language to know exactly what the bill does and how it does it, but I’m pleased to see the long tradition of spinning this by the control movement continuing.

More Details on the Cornyn Bill

Looks like this will be the vehicle to thwart their plans to put 4 million plus Social Security recipients who have designated a “representative payee” into NICS, and put a stop to the VA’s habit of putting veterans in there who aren’t managing their own affairs. From NRA a few minutes ago:

FAIRFAX, Va. — The National Rifle Association’s Institute for Legislative Action (NRA-ILA) today announced its support for legislation that would protect the constitutional rights of millions of veterans and social security recipients. The Mental Health and Safe Communities Act, sponsored by U.S. Senator John Cornyn, contains provisions that would stop the Obama administration’s efforts to deny millions of veterans and social security recipients their Second Amendment rights without due process. 

“The NRA is fighting to stop the Obama administration from denying millions of veterans and social security recipients their Second Amendment rights for no other reason than they want assistance in managing their financial affairs,” said Chris W. Cox, NRA-ILA executive director. “We thank Senator Cornyn for his leadership in standing up to the Obama administration and introducing legislation that will take meaningful steps toward fixing America’s broken mental health system.” 

President Obama’s Department of Veterans Affairs has denied more than 100,000 veterans and dependents their Second Amendment rights because they use a “fiduciary” to manage their benefits. Veterans who the agency determines need help administering their compensation are then labeled “mental defectives” and reported to the National Instant background Check System (NICS), which prohibits them from purchasing or possessing firearms.  The process of assigning a fiduciary does not require the VA to consider whether a veteran poses a danger to himself or others. 

In addition, the Social Security Administration announced that it is moving forward with a proposal that would strip the Second Amendment rights of more than 4.2 million people, by reporting social security recipients who use a “representative payee” to help them manage their benefits to the NICS.

Details of the legislation include:

  • The bill will stop the Obama administration’s Social Security Administration and other agencies from defining as “prohibited persons” those who meet arbitrary criteria such as having a representative payee assigned to their account.
  • The bill will stop the Obama administration’s Veterans Administration (VA) from throwing veterans into NICS simply for having a fiduciary assigned to their account.
  • Veterans who have been swept into NICS under previous VA rules will be given the opportunity to have their case reviewed in a full hearing. Requires a specific finding that the veteran is a danger to self or others. Veterans who are not found to be a danger will have their rights restored and will be removed from NICS.
  • Requires that real adjudications take place before an individual can be determined a prohibited person under federal law. Full notice, hearing, the right to participate, and the right to counsel are required.
  • Provides funding for the states to forward records of mental health adjudications which meet the new due process requirements outlined in the bill.
  • Recognizes state orders restoring the firearms rights of individuals under state law.
  • Requires AG to remove individuals from NICS in cases where rights have been restored or procedures failed to provide adequate due process protections, as with the VA program.

UPDATE: A later release had more bullet points. I have updated this post to reflect the later bullet points.

Weekly Gun News – Edition 10

Today looks to be a slow news day for guns, so hopefully this tab clearing won’t leave me high and dry for the rest of the week.

NRA and Planned Parenthood are both more popular than any of the Presidential candidates.

Vapid celebrities teaming up with slimy politicians to push gun control? OMG! We’ve never seen anything like this before. Surely they will have us on the ropes any day now.

More on the effort to legalize hunting with semi-automatic firearms in Pennsylvania.

More efforts by medical professionals to undermine Second Amendment rights. I’d note that the National Physicians Alliance is a left-wing group that supports gun control, and who receive funding from the Joyce Foundation and Tides Foundation.

Bear hunting targeted in Florida. If there’s one thing the Cecil the Lion fiasco should teach us it’s that hunting is in serious trouble.

Delta and American are giving in to the hysteria and banning safari hunting trophies.

Lawmakers are joining Bloomberg in an attempt to bully Cabela’s and Bass Pro to stop doing default proceeds.

If you negligently shoot your daughter when you’re teaching her gun safety, you’re doing it wrong.

This video of Ted Cruz is making the rounds. I’m not a fan. Not only wouldn’t I want to eat anything that’s touched my rifle barrel, but I don’t like perpetuating public confusion over the difference between a semi-auto and a machine gun.

Gizmodo: Lion hunter has done more for conservation than most of the people bitching.

TownHall looks at the story about what happens when you put untrained people in a police simulator. I’m wondering if they even explained to them how the thing works. Otherwise, it’s like watching a movie, which people are used to doing passively. Very different than fighting for your actual life.

Hunting making a comeback in the UK? In other news, it looks like the Tories have bigger nuts than the GOP.

John Lott repsonds to a hit piece from Mother Jones.

Even some of CSGV’s mouth foaming supporters can’t stomach their cartoonish views.

British Police discover deadly bike wheel on weapons sweep. A quick search online shows this isn’t so crazy after all!

CycleWeapon

Cornyn Introducing New Mental Health Bill

We’ll Be Watching for Language, since I have not seen any yet. John Cornyn is introducing the “Mental Health and Safe Communities Act” today, which the NRA is already endorsing. It looks like a mix of straight-up mental health funding, along with some more incentives for reporting mental health firearm disabilities to the FBI. Without language, I don’t have much analysis to offer, except that we’ve seen several of these reporting bills become law, and there are several states that still aren’t reporting. I don’t know how much more incentive can be offered, and the feds can’t force them to report anything.

Usually you see this kind of thing run when there’s lawmakers who for one reason or another, want some cover from the “something must be done!” crowd, so they can argue they did “something.” I do know Bloomberg is trying to run a competing bill that, needless to say, probably goes further than this one will.

I sincerely hope this isn’t a sign that politicians are becoming afraid of Bloomberg’s money. In the past, the gun control movement hasn’t had the money to run “Congressman Spineless voted against keeping guns out of the hands of crazy people, and against commonsense gun reforms that will save the lives of our children. Send Congressman Spinless a message this fall; our children are more important than the evil gun lobby.” Bloomberg’s money changes that.

True Derp Confessions

SayUncle admits to some of his past derpitude. This is a good exercise I think, because when we all first got into this, we probably did a lot of derpy things. I am no exception. Let me admit to mine:

  • I first got my License to Carry in 2002. At the time, I was looking to buy a Walther PPK/S. I let a gun store clerk talk me into a Bersa Thunder .380.
  • The first time I carried the Bersa outside the house, it was in an Uncle Mike’s sausage sack in the small of the back, loaded with Hydra-shoks. That’s just what I had. A few months later, I bought a Glock 19 (same one I still carry today) and a decent holster and stopped carrying the Bersa, which later broke.
  • When I first started buying guns, my criteria was basically whether it looked like something the politicians would like to ban soon. Among my early purchases were a Hi-Point 9mm carbine (which I do still occasionally shoot, but they are basically made from pot metal and noticeably destroy themselves as you shoot them), and a CM-11 carbine (which never reliably fired more than 40 shots).
  • Like Uncle, I also had an AR with a scope mounted on the carry handle.
  • I own an AR-15 in 6.8 Remington SPC.

These days I’m not really buying guns, both for lack of time and money. I’m more interested in historical collecting these days anyway. On my current WANT list is a decent Krag-Jorgensen, and a Trap Door Springfield. I try to avoid gun shows these days, because I will occasionally see a decent specimen of these and get very tempted to spend money I shouldn’t. The Derp has not completely left me, however. I still have an irrational desire for a Kriss Vector.