I think Michael’s correct here that competition a useful training tool. Though, it looks like he’s speaking mostly of IPSC and IDPA, which I’ve had no experience with. Silhouette shooting is not really an adrenaline pumping game. Mostly taking slow, deliberately and carefully aimed shots. Nonetheless, I’ve had more than a few cases where I can knock animals down like there’s no tomorrow in practice, only to perform poorly once I get on the line. Knowing “this one is for the marbles” tweaks you up a bit, and you can’t hold as steady.
I do wish I could do IPSC competition, but the rules at my club make it impossible, and I don’t know any of the other clubs in the area that do it. I don’t really have time to drive out to rural Pennsylvania on a regular basis to compete. There is a local indoor range that does non-sanctioned IDPA matches, and it happens to be my favorite indoor range. Maybe I’ll have to give that a whirl at some point.
I think there’s a lot of clubs that are stuck in old ways. Practical shooting looks like it’s fun, exciting, and there’s a lot of folks who seem to really enjoy doing it. When I have watched the IDPA matches at the indoor range, I see a lot of young people getting into it. That tends to make me think this is a growing sport, whereas the traditional types of sports done at my club are mostly older guys. At 34, I’m pretty young compared to a lot of them. But I think to traditionalists, IDPA and IPSC shooting seem unsafe, and most of the clubs I’ve looked into have rules that prevent that kind of match from ever taking place. I tend to think clubs will need to adapt in this regard or face dwindling participation in organized events. I know one disappointment of my club is that, although we have 1100 members, hardly anyone participates in organized matches, except for trap events. Most people are just thinking of it as a place to plink every now and then. I suppose that’s fine, but I think different types of shooting sports might get more people involved, and help build a sense of community that I think is important in a shooting club. That requires gun owners to think different, and adopt new ideas, which I think we’re extraordinarily bad at. I think it’s more than just the industry that’s resistant to change. It’s a strong cultural inclination within the entire shooting community.