In this case, the USDA imposed on the Hornes a â€œmarketing orderâ€ demanding that they turn over 47% of their crop without compensation. Â The orderâ€”a much-criticized New Deal relicâ€”forces raisin â€œhandlersâ€ to reserve a certain percentage of their crop â€œfor the accountâ€ of the government-backed Raisin Administrative Committee, enabling the government to control the supply and price of raisins on the market. Â The RAC then either sells the raisins or simply gives them away to noncompetitive marketsâ€”such as federal agencies, charities, and foreign governmentsâ€”with the proceeds going toward the RACâ€™s administration costs.
Their case is currently before the US Supreme Court on the grounds that this constitutes a taking, and therefore is in violation of the 5th Amendment. I can’t see how it isn’t so. Then again, I thought “public use” was pretty clear too.
I don’t understand why more people don’t get worked up over this stuff. To me this is an outrage. Everyone ought to think it’s an outrage. Is it that there are just too many outrages these days? Too many people think you can’t fight city hall? Do people on the left really agree with this kind of nonsense?