Even the roughest cut at the question shows that substantial swath of the Black community would reject Whitlockâ€™s thesis. National polling by the Pew Research Center recently asked,Â â€œWhat do you think is more important â€“ to protect the right of Americans to own guns, or to control gun ownership?â€ Fifty-four percent of whites and 30 percent of Blacks said it was more important to protect gun rights. Respondents were also asked â€œShould States and Localities be able to pass laws banning handguns?â€ 64 percent of Blacks said yes and 30 percent said no.Â Based on these results, Whitlock must conclude that a third of the Black community are Klan sympathizers.Â And that actually is the least absurd implication of his â€œanalysis.â€
And that’s only looking at national surveys with very small samples of blacks. Read the whole thing. He goes on to plug his upcoming law review, which I have read a draft of. It’s quite good and I look forward to it coming out:
Whitlockâ€™s commentary is also problematic at another level that I elaborate in detail in my forthcoming article,Â Firearms Law and The Black Community:An Assessment Of The Modern OrthodoxyÂ (Connecticut Law Review) and a forthcoming book based on that research, â€œNegros with Guns: The Dual Tradition of Non-Violent Social Change and Individual Self-Defense (Prometheus).Â This work explains that the basic premise of the modern gun control movement â€“ that people should rely on government for personal security- is wildly at odds with the Black experience in America. No group in the nation has better reason to doubt the competency and benevolence of the state. For most of the Black experience in America, the state has been an overt menace.
This is going to be an important new work for waging the culture war against gun control.