search
top

ANJRPC/SAF File Civil Rights Suit Against New Jersey

For a while now, many have wondered when New Jersey was going to get sued for their gun laws. The answer to that question would appear to be right now:

TRENTON, N.J., Nov. 22, 2010 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ — The Association of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs (ANJRPC) announced today that it has joined in a federal lawsuit challenging a provision of New Jersey law that effectively denies law-abiding citizens the civil right to defend themselves with a firearm outside the home.

The suit, brought together with The Second Amendment Foundation and six private citizens, challenges the constitutionality of New Jersey’s extreme and subjective “justifiable need” standard for issuance of handgun carry permits – a nearly impossible standard to meet that has all but eliminated the right of self defense with a firearm in the Garden State.

“The fundamental right to defend yourself does not evaporate when you walk out your front door,” said ANJRPC President Scott Bach. “The U.S. Supreme Court has recently made it clear that this right belongs to all Americans.  This lawsuit will ensure thatNew Jersey finally stops denying its citizens this basic freedom.”

40 states currently have laws recognizing the right of law-abiding citizens to carry a handgun for self defense, 28 of which have been enacted in just the last two decades. Despite the mountain of evidence showing that sustained reductions in violent crime rates result after enactment of these laws,(1) New Jersey has refused to modernize its own laws, instead choosing to imperil its citizens and force them to remain defenseless victims against armed criminals who don’t follow the law.

“It’s no mystery why violent crime rates plummet wherever right to carry laws are enacted,” said Bach.  “Criminals go somewhere else when they think their victims might be armed.  When predators can’t tell the difference between the sheep and the wolves, the whole flock is safer.”

One of the plaintiffs in the new lawsuit is a kidnap victim, another is a part-time sheriff’s deputy, a third carries large amounts of cash in his private business and another is a civilian employee of a law enforcement agency.  The fact that such persons are unable to qualify for a New Jersey carry permit underscores how arbitrary and unreasonable the Garden State’s laws are.  “New Jersey’s carry laws are blatantly unconstitutional,” said Bach.  “We intend to change that.”

I will have more information on this suit as it becomes available.

UPDATE: I’ve linked to the federal complaint here.

6 Responses to “ANJRPC/SAF File Civil Rights Suit Against New Jersey”

  1. I wonder when Bryan Miller is gonna have a press release. It should be a good one this time…..

  2. Dannytheman says:

    FASTER, please!!!!!!

  3. Pete says:

    Man Alan and Alan are becoming some of the greatest civil rights heroes of all time.

    I wish I had $$ to donate to them.

  4. Paul says:

    About time. I’m a member of the SAF and ANJRPC (NRA affiliate in NJ) and I just made donations to both in honor of this. We really, really need some relief in this state. For those of you who have written NJ off — bad move. You might like to think that it is “occupied territory” or a foreign country, but the reality is that as long as the absurd, irrational and, most importantly blatantly unconstitutional gun laws in this state are allowed to stand, it puts the rights of all Americans at risk. You may think it can’t happen in Texas or Georgia, but as long as the NJ paradigm of ignoring and violating constitutional rights is allowed to stand, no one is really safe.

  5. Dean Speir says:

    Pete, read more closely… this isn’t an Alan Gura case. It’s been prepared and filed by attorneys Robert P. Firriolo and David D. Jensen.

    My understanding is that Gura will consult and Gottlieb/SAF will partially underwrite.

  6. Sebastian says:

    Apparently fully underwrite. I made the assumption it was jointly funded, but apparently SAF is picking up the bill, though the case asks for attorneys fees.

top